Asking a Question Does Not Make You Agree to an Adverse Answer.

Texas Supreme Court Justice Phil Johnson

Mr. Ali wants to buy a business from Mr. Musallam. They negotiate and they make an appointment to finish the deal. When the time comes Musallam does not want to sell. Ali sues. Musallam says that he owes nothing because they had not finished reaching an agreement. The case is tried to a jury. Musallam requests a charge question as to whether or not the two men had a deal. The jury finds for Ali. After the verdict, Musallam makes two complaints to the trial court:

1. that the jury finding was immaterial, and
2. that the jury finding was supported by insufficient evidence.

Immaterial, what does that mean? It means that there are many reasons that one person might be legally bound to owe money to another person. The money might be owed for some other reason than that there was a breach of contract-- detrimental reliance for one.

In Fort Worth's State Court of Appeals, Justice Lee Gabriel wrote an opinion for a panel including now former Chief Justice Terri Livingston and Justice Mark T. Pittman, denying Musallam relief because he could not complain that a jury question that he asked for was not material and for which there was insufficient evidence. Musallam petitioned the Texas Supreme Court to review the case. They agreed, and Supreme Court Justice Phil Johnson wrote for a unanimous SCOTX that Musallam had not waived his alleged error and that the case should be remanded to Fort Worth to be considered on the merits. The Supremes said that if someone seeks a jury question, it does not follow that one is agreeing to be bound by any answer that may be made to that question and that one is not vouching for the sufficiency of the evidence in favor of an adverse ruling.

Texas Supreme Court Justices are not created equal, but Phil Johnson, whose resignation took effect yesterday appeared to me to be one of the good ones. He appeared to call balls and strikes and not to have any dark nor ignorant agenda. I include video from his last oral argument, which choked me up. So long, Justice Johnson. Thank you for all your public service.

https://pbvideo.vids.io/videos/d49ddebc1710ecc15c/justice-phil-johnson-retires-from-the-supreme-court-of-texas